ABOUT

  • Mainly about engagement and collaboration using social media and events, with some asides on living in London. More about David Wilcox and also how the blog started.
  • Search

    WWW
    http://partnerships.typepad.com/civic/

« Should social researchers practice good practice too? | Main | Boardroom tip: value the awkward squad too »

Nonprofit support 'hubs' row spreads

Third Sector magazine is now really on to the controversy about specialist hubs to support the UK Government's Changeup plans to strengthen the voluntary and community (nonprofit) sectors. They have a story this week about the Governance hub.

Foundation for Good Governance researcher and spokeswoman Christine Morrison said Changeup is the wrong model because it imposes a centralised structure on a sector that is based on networks of support organisations, membership bodies, councils for voluntary service and local development agencies.
"There is little doubt that the Government's intentions are well-meaning - but unfortunately the model proposed for support is unlikely to work because it seeks to impose a top-down approach on a sector that thrives on diversity," she said.

The article references the Communities of Practice session we ran last week at a conference with Christine to demonstrate alternative approaches.
Third Sector also reports that the Home Office has stepped into the row about the IT hub that I wrote about earlier.
From the latter piece it is clear that the Home Office is still determined to get one proposal from the sector for each hub, and they see competing consortia as unseemly squabbling. The point Christine Morrison is making is that we need some diversity.
Don't hold your breath for rapprochement on the 'one bid' front, though.
ICT Consortium project manager Nicky Thompson, who works for the NCVO, said: "The consortium has always welcomed, and would still welcome, input from other organisations with expertise to share. The Home Office has shown confidence that the ICT Consortium was best placed to take this work forward, and indeed funded us to do so."

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c266753ef00d83458cafb69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Nonprofit support 'hubs' row spreads:

» Thinking about partnerships and participation with David Wilcox from Headshift
Background on our work with David Wilcox to produce a web site management tool that combines blog, RSS aggregator, wiki and content management to offer a simple social software solution to networks and small organisations.

[Read More]

» Thinking about partnerships and participation with David Wilcox from Headshift
Background on our work with David Wilcox to produce a web site management tool that combines blog, RSS aggregator, wiki and content management to offer a simple social software solution to networks and small organisations. [Read More]

» Governance hub business plan published from David Wilcox
Last year I wrote at Designing for Civil Society about the UK Government's Changeup initiative to improve how the nonprofit sector operates, and in particular rumbling of discontent about plans for a single hub as the focus for expertise... [Read More]

» Governance hub business plan published from David Wilcox

Organisations developing a hub of expertise on nonprofit governance for the UK have now produced their business plan.

[Read More]

» Scrap the nonprofit hubs: just join up what's here already from David Wilcox
I wrote last year, at Designing for Civil Society, about the row between different consortia seeking to set up a 'hub' providing advice and support on the use of technology by nonprofits - links below. As Third Sector magazine... [Read More]

» Scrap the nonprofit hubs: just join up what's here already from David Wilcox

An independent assessor has criticised all parties in the row about a 'hub' to provide advice and support to UK nonprofits. But do we really need these centralised systems anyway?

[Read More]

Comments

The comments to this entry are closed.